Eugene Perelshteyn wrote: > Carol, > Yes, going into the event it was our understanding that we would not > be eligible to play in the final in case we win 1st. I believe Steve > Doyle mentioned it to Roman, and we were fine with this. > Either way, we are not interested to play in the final as it will be > online. Our goal was to have fun, play next to each other > over-the-board, and enjoy the great atmosphere of the tournament. > You can contact the 2nd place team. > Best, > Eugene > --- Carol Jarecki wrote: >> Hi Eugene, >> There is some misunderstanding, and lots of controversy, regarding >> your team's acceptance into the Playoff. >> As you said, the team members understood they could not play, as >> established in past years, because of it's rating configuration. >> Since the restriction wasn't in writing in the East's TLA Steve Doyle >> feels the team is allowed although others disagree, asserting the >> rule of not more than a 1000-point difference between boards 3 and 4 >> has been in place for so long that it no longer needs annual >> publication. This has caused such national contoversy that he has >> gone so far as to suggest the Playoffs be cancelled this year. This >> would be very unfortunate and most likely would not be agreed. >> I need to know if I may contact the second-place team to partipate in >> the Playoffs on April 12th which would satisfactorily resolve this >> problem in the interest, intention and tradition of the US Amateur >> Team tournaments. >> Many thanks for a quick reply and cooperation. >> Carol >>
What's your source of information? And why were they excluded?
ReplyDeleteThis is from comments on Lizzy's blog
ReplyDeleteEugene Perelshteyn wrote:
> Carol,
> Yes, going into the event it was our understanding that we would not
> be eligible to play in the final in case we win 1st. I believe Steve
> Doyle mentioned it to Roman, and we were fine with this.
> Either way, we are not interested to play in the final as it will be
> online. Our goal was to have fun, play next to each other
> over-the-board, and enjoy the great atmosphere of the tournament.
> You can contact the 2nd place team.
> Best,
> Eugene
> --- Carol Jarecki wrote:
>> Hi Eugene,
>> There is some misunderstanding, and lots of controversy, regarding
>> your team's acceptance into the Playoff.
>> As you said, the team members understood they could not play, as
>> established in past years, because of it's rating configuration.
>> Since the restriction wasn't in writing in the East's TLA Steve Doyle
>> feels the team is allowed although others disagree, asserting the
>> rule of not more than a 1000-point difference between boards 3 and 4
>> has been in place for so long that it no longer needs annual
>> publication. This has caused such national contoversy that he has
>> gone so far as to suggest the Playoffs be cancelled this year. This
>> would be very unfortunate and most likely would not be agreed.
>> I need to know if I may contact the second-place team to partipate in
>> the Playoffs on April 12th which would satisfactorily resolve this
>> problem in the interest, intention and tradition of the US Amateur
>> Team tournaments.
>> Many thanks for a quick reply and cooperation.
>> Carol
>>